Decision Quality Audit

No, failure has not been written down

Only discussed informally

Yes, the failure path is written and reviewable

No explicit kill criteria

Rough criteria exist, but not owned

Yes, clear criteria and owners exist

No reference class

Anecdotes or one-off examples

Comparable internal cases

External benchmark or market data

Mostly intuition

Expert judgement, but no model

Simple model with assumptions

Model anchored to a measured distribution

No classification

Classified as reversible

Classified as one-way-door

Classified, with governance matched to reversibility

No rollback or containment plan

Rough fallback path

Owned rollback plan with triggers

No pre-mortem

Informal discussion only

Cross-functional pre-mortem completed

No indicators

Only lagging outcome metrics

Leading indicators and review cadence are defined

No decision log

Loose notes only

Structured decision log

No clear success measures

Outcome metrics only

Both process and outcome measures